Apple building a search engine frontend?

Thu, 11/13/2008 - 08:03 — Chauncey Dupree

According to TechCrunch and their multiple sources, Apple is building a search engine to take on Google and Yahoo.  While it seems far fetched at first. (little expertise, no advertising model, etc.) Tech Crunch does raise a good point that Apple may be trying to enhance the experience for their users and could just be putting some Apple window dressing on another serch engine's backend.

But one important fact that isn’t checking out - if Apple were building a search engine, they’d be hiring search experts and engineers. We’ve talked to a ton of them at all the big companies, and while some of them heard the same rumors, none have lost search employees to Apple, or heard of any specific hirings.

That alone almost certainly rules out a full on search competitor. You can’t do it without people who know what they’re doing.

Apple also loves the fees they receive regularly from Google for search marketing dollars earned from Safari. They obviously aren’t in the advertising business today, so even if they did launch a search engine they’d still heavily rely on Google or its competitors for the advertising piece. So why invest all that capital into search?

The answer is they’re not. But the rumors persist, and we believe they have a nugget of truth. Here’s what we think is really going on: Apple doesn’t like the search experience on its mobile devices, and may be building a radically different user experience which is much more visual than exists today. It will likely still be powered by Google results, but Apple may present it in a very different way that suits mobile users much better.

Stay tuned for more. There are pieces of this we are still putting together.

( Filed Under: )

Comments

Apple Search?

I think they'd have to have a pretty good reason to modify the front end for Google or alike. With Apple's close partnership with Google maybe it'd just be an extension for google from Spotlight?

Apple + Google

This is what I see:

  1. Apple has a fantastic design team.
  2. Google has by far the best search engine technology.
  3. Google has a really boring interface.
  4. Spotlight has a good interface, but opening a Safari history item just launches Safari, which reveals it in the Finder.
  5. Spotlight does not have any web integration.
  6. Apple gets money from Google search and branding throughout their systems.

I think that Apple may either be building a custom front end to Google, or integrating it into Spotlight. More likely than either, however, is them building a custom front end for Google on the iPhone.

~ KA

Sherlock

Anybody else having flashbacks to that old app "Sherlock"?
Discontinued in Leopard (which saddened me - I used it a lot)

Pretty plausible...

Now that you guys bring up the Google partnership, I can definitely see this being pulled off.

Google is the best search engine out there so far, but it just uses text. If Apple could pull off something with a less verbal, more visual approach, this venture would be huge!

Apple and Google are joining

I know it sounds stupid... but just think for a second how ¨goople¨ (Apple + Google) could be the most powerful company EVER.
the only thing they would have left is to buy:
Sony
Bose

and when theyll have enough money, buy microsoft as well!

why would anyone want to buy

why would anyone want to buy bose? all they make is over-priced garbage for people with too much money and zero knowledge about audio tech.

Don't forget Adobe!

Don't forget Adobe!

~ KA

False headlines

If they aren't, then why say they are in the headline??

For the App Store...

The App Store is need for a good search. I can very much see a more powerful search than the title and description text search that exists right now. Apps are going by the hundreds if not the thousands every month. It's a natural fit. Oh yeah, how about advertising in those search results. :)

apple building a search engine

The last line of the article tells me you don't know what you're talking about ("You can’t do it without people who know what they’re doing."). The Feds do "it" all the time with people who don't have a clue as to what they're doing.

Apple Building a Search Engine

Is this really far-fetched? If Apple and Google are so synergistic, then why is Google spending a ton of capital and resources on something called Android? What planet are you people living on commenting on their love for each other? Right now, it's just business, but they both know they can't rely on each other.

Google is worried Apple is getting too powerful and can start their own search engine, as Apple is all too familiar of trying to close its doors on making money off of Apple products (examples include rejecting application on the App Store that directly compete with or mimic core Apple features or planned features).

Apple is worried that if they rely too heavily on Google, and there's no competition in the search market, what's to keep them from jacking their prices in the future? Plus, why collect ad-partnership commissions when you can collect the entire ad fee by having your own search engine?

The only reason Google and Apple are working together right now is business, and they're both competing with Microsoft. But Android is a direct slap in the face to Apple's iPhone OS. There were even quite specific comments made from one another.

As for hiring search experts and engineers, how would big companies know? Especially with NDA's and such. They could also be hiring fresh grads and others in related fields to take a different approach instead of common industry standards to differentiate themselves. They could also acquire a search company like http://www.cuil.com/ and be working on how to integrate it and have the "product(s)" ready before announcing the acquisition, which would send of flags to all their competitors. They may even be looking into buying Yahoo (which could have been one of Microsoft's reasons to attempt to buy Yahoo, or say the were interested in doing so, also).

http://netcrime.itproportal.com/articles/2008/11/16/5-reasons-why-apple-...

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This question is used to make sure you are a human visitor and to prevent spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.